Are Philly Cheesesteaks Overrated?
So last night, I’m at the Garden State Mall seeing The Dictator. Contrary to KFC’s thoughts on Sacha Baron Cohen’s newest release, it was fucking awesome. But that’s a debate for another day. Today’s issue deals with what went down before the movie even started. We’re in the food court about a half hour prior to show time, trying to decide what to eat. When Philly Cheesesteak was thrown in the ring, I promptly stated how overrated these sandwiches are. Never in the history of sandwich has the Philly cheesesteak done anything to warrant its critical acclaim as THE sandwich. In my opinion, it’s a good couple bites, but I find myself quickly getting tired of the taste. Same thing with caramel. My opinions were not well received.
To help solve the debate, while simultaneously attempting to impress the girl I was with by showing her how big my Twitter cock is, I posted this:
And holy shit, I haven’t seen this much hatred for pizza boy since I called Jeter an MVP candidate in mid April. When I left the theatre after the movie, I turned my phone on to see an angry mob of twitter followers calling for my head. I was stunned that I was one of the few who share this sentiment. Challenged by the expert on useless shit, I was instigated by KFC to put together a list (in no particular order) of sandwiches that I would choose over a cheesesteak:
1. Anything chicken cutlet. Breaded chicken cutlet could be thrown on thumbtacks and I would eat it over a Philly Cheesesteak. The BCC food group includes all the fan favorites- chicken parm, chicken BLT, chicken ranch, etc. Too much versatility in the chicken cutlet game.
2. The Gobbler from Ted’s Deli (2 locations) in Northern New Jersey. A seasonal delicacy, the Thanksgiving themed blend of turkey, stuffing, and cranberry sauce makes a Philly Cheesesteak look like an eggplant parm.
3. The Napoli from Lotito’s in Mahwah- Couldn’t even tell you what’s on it. Never even asked. I never had to because the second I saw it, I knew it was right. Something chicken/hot peppery though.
4. Fieldworker- Made popular by The Bagel Shop next to St. Joe’s in Montvale, NJ, the key to a well-executed Fieldworker is the delicate balance of egg and homefries when mixed together with the taylor ham. I promised myself to not bring egg sandwiches into the debate, as that could open pandora’s box, but fieldworkers are that fucking good.
And that’s just 4 of them. Sausage and peppers, brisket, pulled pork, hell, I’ll even take a well made italian combo from Cosmo’s in Hackensack over a Philly Cheesesteak. But there are 2 consistencies in the sandwich game that I feel pretty confident everyone agrees on. A. If you’re not putting chips on a majority of your sandwiches, you’re doing it wrong. B. The guy who invented the diagonal cut to replace the horizontal cut for heroes is a true innovator. Best food packaging advancement since the 2 overlapping plates to fit 2 slices of pizza in 1 bag move. I can’t even fathom what people did before that. 2 separate bags? Archaic.
Vote 1 for I’m just a sheep in the endless herd of mindless idiots who think Philly Cheesesteaks are the end-all, be-all of sandwiches or vote 10 for overrated.





roast beef 3 way from just about any sub shop north of boston not named kelly’s kicks the shit out of a philly cheesesteak
Sandwich places in the city or fuck off. No one cares about the JV team. Grow some balls and cross the Hudson.
Steak and Cheese subs in Massachusetts are so much fucking better than shitty ass Philly Steak and Cheeses. Fucking cheap ass fucking cheese wiz bullshit. Steak and Cheese with extra cheese from Super Sub in Beverly will bend a Philly Steak and Cheese sub over the table and anally rape it.
you are so fuckin off….any time you are saying a local place is better than a philly cheese steak you are comparing apples to oranges….theres a reason why everyone in the world tries to imitate a philly cheese steak, cause its better than any of the fuckin podunk local sandwich shops version of the real philly cheese steak
Only steak & cheese sandwich (Cheesesteak is a stupid name) I get is from the Fours in Boston (the Bobby Orr sandwich). Real steak tips on that motherfucker, not that proccessed shaved steak bullshit.
Id rather eat Subway on a subway than that dog meat from philly.
Any cheesesteak made outside of Philly simply isn’t a Philly cheesesteak. Even most of the ones made in Philly aren’t really Philly cheesesteaks.
End-all-be-all? Nah probably not. But you can’t say Philly cheesesteaks are overrated because you find some shitty New Jersey knock off underwhelming. Like there’s no fat dude from Philly jetting all over the place checking on the quality of that shit, they just call it whatever they want.
Also it’s common knowledge that how clean the establishment is and how nice the neighborhood you find it in is inversely proportional to how good your cheesesteak is. That’s why Philthydelphia makes ‘em the best. Mall cheesesteak = horseshit, everytime.
Overrated. I’ll take a Turker over a Philly any day of the week. Ditto on the breaded chicken cutlet deal; Just so many options, and all of them taste good.
I’ll have to stop by Lotito’s during lunch next week. Never been, but local is good.
Just silly, when you are ordering “Philly” cheesesteaks in a north jersey food court and talking about the sandwich being overrated you are a fool. It would be like going to Olive Garden and talking about how meatballs are overrated, or watching the lingerie league and determining football is lame, just silly.
Man up, go to Chinks, or better yet Donkey’s in Camden and tell me the sandwich is overrated.
http://www.yelp.com/biz/donkeys-place-camden
Fuck you dickhead. Take your “hero” and shove it up your ass. The reason you don’t like Philly cheesesteaks is probably because you’re buying them in north jersey shopping malls you fuck. If you’re not buying a Philly cheesesteak in Philly, it’s just a cheesesteak. Wouldn’t expect a moron pizza delivery boy to understand that though.
By the way, the food court at G.S.P. is ass to begin with.
i went to college in philly and within the first month i hit genos and it sucked. so i went to pats and it sucked. so i hit ricks and it sucked. and finally rounded it out with jims and it sucked. i gave it my best try but the philly cheesesteak is hands down the most overrated sandwich in existence.
You might want to be a little more generic when making comparisons. The only people that know what you are talking about have ordered those specific sandwiches at those shops. So this post basically boils down to you telling everybody what your favorite sandwiches are at your local deli. Thanks for letting us know, I know I appreciate it.
The Philly Cheeseteak isn’t even the best sandwich in Philly. The Italian Roast Pork w/ Provolone or Roast Beef at DiNics puts the cheesesteak to shame!
you couldn’t put together a collection of sandwiches that are national or that other people can relate to? jesus strasser, have you never left new jersey? every place you named is a sandwich shop that i’ve never and will never ever go to.
Comparing a cheesesteak as a whole to specific sandwiches from a certain local spot is retarded. Also, comparing a cheesesteak from a real philly place to anywhere else is pointless. And if anyone mentions pats or genos as the best cheesesteak they’re just not from philly
1.) Cluckin Russian greatest sandwich ever made.
If you don’t know what that is learn.
Also Delassandro’s in Roxborough is the best in the city, or Steve’s prince of steaks
Cheesesteak hoagie reigns supreme. I know there’s a lot of Philly hate, but if you’re ever in the city of brotherly love, do yourself a favor and grab a cheesesteak (with provolone, wiz is for tourists) hoagie from either Jim’s or Tony Lukes. If you can’t get down with that, then I don’t know what to tell you.
Otwisted, the Bobby Orr is incredible.
For the record, if Philly produced a cure for cancer, how long before assholes from Boston found a ridiculous reason to talk shit on it? Easily the most delusional population in the country.
lotito’s is in ramsey homie
hate philly cheese steaks. tastes like the ass of a cow. BUT HATE JERSEY MORE
Pizza Boy. As a former Green Knight and constant at the Bagel Shop in Montvale, you have to go with the Holy Grail over field worker any day. Get it on an everything bagel crushed and its amazing. This sandwich list is sort of week too. But a real Philly cheese steak with cheese whiz is absolutely killer and you cannot deny that. If you have had a real cheese steak then you know, even chicken cheese steaks are great. You have to have the shitty steak with the onions and whiz… thats what makes it…
PHILLY SUCKS
FRENCH DIP IF NOT YOUR AN IDIOT
FRENCH DIP IF NOT YOUR AN IDIOT
FRENCH DIP IF NOT YOUR AN IDIOT
FRENCH DIP IF NOT YOUR AN IDIOT
FRENCH DIP IF NOT YOUR AN IDIOT
Italian Combo with olive oil vinegar and roasted red peppers or a chicken salad sub are better than a cheese steak unless the cheese steak is from philly. period.
Garden State Mall? Haha. What… no time to make it into the city between GTL sessions with Pauly D and the boys? And really, if you’re going to rep jersey sandwich shops, at least go with hoagie haven, which as far as I can tell is the only reason to enter the worst state in the union.
rinehart…nobody outside of Philly tried to imitate a Philly cheesesteak…I’ve had maybe 3 in my entire life because I never see them sold ANYWHERE…and I’ve lived in NY NJ CA AZ NM DC…Philly people need to get over themselves…I consider myself a tri-state guy and even I don’t claim the rest of the country tries to imitate our Pizza
by the way The Honey Sub Special at what used to be Neil’s Nosh in Martinsville NJ is a gamechanger
Camerons 24/7 deli South Salem, NY. Cluckin Russian. You are welcome.
how is anyone going to tell me they dont like steak cooked with peppers and onions on a hero roll with some cheese melted over it? its like theres 50,000 losers hoping their out of control insane comment will get them the next guest blogging spot. I just wanna talk about some damn sandwiches
This Cluckin Russian sounds intriguing.
Greatest sandwich ever made.
Holy Grail= Two Eggs, Cheese, Bacon, Taylor Ham on an everything bagel.
Crushed=pressed on the panninni machine
Taylor Ham is a dumb fucking name. It’s called pork roll. And it’s the second best breakfast meat know to man. Bacon trumps all, but pork roll is fucking tits.
KFC, again, PLEASE fire this idiot. Such a horrible blogger
Who is Strasser? And more importantly when did baseball start playing again?
the fact that you have chicken cutlet at no. 1 just shows that you have no fucking clue what you are talking about. blandest sub in the game. cheese steaks are a powerhouse you should be ashamed of yourself
pulled pork is the best though
Dots3 pleaseeee fucking kill yourself immediately. I am from Philadelphia and go to school at UMass and you are fucking delusional if you think a steak and cheese is remotely close to a cheesesteak. Fuck yourself
All of you commentors are degenerates you know nothing of good food in new jersey. Godfather at milburn deli in milburn and sloppy joe at hickory tree in chatam. all i need to say
It’s an insult to manly food all over the world that this blog exists. The top two sandwiches on this list are CHICKEN? Sure. Sounds fantastic. Enjoy. You’re gay.
MOOGY’S in Brighton, Mass. Literally anything they make is better than any cheesesteak I’ve had in Philly. You can’t hate on the concept of cheese + steak, but there is so much better things out there. Maybe it’s my inner greaseball but cheese + pomodoro sauce + anything on bread = delicious.
If you put a chicken parm sub over a steak and cheese you are a fucking child.
@dudebro Exactly right. That’s like saying you like Spahetti-O’s more than Roma tomatoes over homemade pasta. Just kid stuff. Like this entire blog.
fuck you
Diagonal cut sandwiches suck and so do you.
Pizza Boy you are fucken retarded Im pretty sure KFC wasn’t telling you to blog a list of shitty sandwich shops in buttfuck NJ that your only 3 friends in the world that live in that shithole can comment on
strasser your such an asshole- why are you comparing specific sandwiches from local places to the cheesesteak? males no sense. also fuck jersey you herb.
The only people that may be more overly sensitive about their regional “delicacy” than Philly people are about their cheesesteaks are Buffalo people when it comes to buffalo wings. Insufferable. The ironic thing is it’s not like making either one is like doing a coq au vin or beef wellington. Both pretty simple. Not a hell of a lot to fuck up.
Strasser, you gotta hit up Wilke’s Deli in Oakland. It’s right next to Mahwah, just hop on 202 from Ramapo College. Their sandwiches are really good, too. Try the Althea, Turkey Club, and the Buffalo Chicken Wrap. If you get the wrap, ask for some of their hot sauce on the side. It’s called ‘Da Bomb’ and is one of the hottest sauces in the world.
THE GODFATHER. TED’S NORTH. BOOM.
Awesome blog bro. Thanks for naming sandwiches you like from your local delis. Love the fact you tell us the name of a sandwich and you can’t even name one f’n ingredient. Chicken/hot peppery, WTF man. How about you call down to this shithole deli and ask whats on the sandwich, numbnuts. Then you start going down the egg sandwich road, c’mon man get it together. You’re all over the place. Just stick to your crappy Yankee blogs nobody cares about jerk off.
My favorite sandwich is the KnobGobbler from the Travolta Deli in Piscataway. No idea what is on it but I really like it. Some type of meat and condiment. Really awesome stuff. I also like bacon, egg and cheese on bagels from various places. The End. Hey can I get my own spot on Barstool. FC95.
A Chicago beef sausage combo with giardiniera and red sauce puts all of this shit to shame.