Giants Prioritizing Nicks Over Cruz Is Obviously The Smart Play
ESPN – For all the talk there has been about the New York Giants signing restricted free agent wide receiver Victor Cruz to a long-term contract, the team is putting a bigger emphasis at this time on signing wide receiver Hakeem Nicks to a long-term deal, according to league sources. Nicks, 25, has one year remaining on his contract, but New York would like to tie him to the team long term as it views him as a legitimate No. 1 receiver. Due to injuries to his knee and foot, Nicks failed to post 1,000 yards receiving for the first time since 2009. It was the first time in three seasons that Nicks did not have at least 76 receptions, 1,000 yards and seven touchdowns in a season. The Giants also would like to keep the 26-year-old Cruz, but at this time, Nicks’ contract status is the higher priority. Giants owner John Mara said last week that he wants Cruz to remain a Giant, but at a reasonable price. “We certainly want him back, but like with any player, there’s a limit to where we’re going to go.”
Well, it’s official. The New York Giants are no longer the defending Super Bowl champs. A murderer came out on top in the Blackout Bowl while San Francisco is telling everyone they were still the better team (sound familiar?) – so it’s time to look ahead to next season. Big Blue certainly have holes to fill – namely at linebacker and on the offensive line – as well as decisions to make on other FA’s (Andre & Stevie Brown, Beatty, Boothe, Black Unicorn should all be back). But easily their most public of off-season decisions will be whether or not Victor Cruz takes his salsa elsewhere. Obviously, in a perfect world, keeping both Nicks & Cruz in blue is the ideal outcome – but prioritizing Nicks with the potential of Victor walking is the right thing to do.
Cruz is a restricted free agent – if he ends up getting tendered then receives an offer from another team which the G-Men don’t match, they’ll get a first-round pick as compensation. Losing Nicks after 2013 gets them nada. And although he’s been around longer, Hakeem’s a year younger than Victor. You could argue that he’s yet to play a full 16, but if you put his two seasons prior to 2012 up against Cruz’ career, the numbers are basically the same. Nicks’ best year was actually in 2010 without Cruz, so he’s proven he can stand on his own just as Eli’s proven he can throw to anyone. Barden & Hixon both had 100-yard games out of nowhere. Besides, look at the recent guys who left NY thinking they could play. Steve Smith. Manningham. Can Cruz succeed as well in the slot without a legit #1 like Nicks on the outside?
Last but not least, Cruz is at peak value. Nicks could be a bargain. So whatever the terms would be for Nicks’ deal set the template for Cruz. Sure, he’d probably pull in a bigger haul from another squad, but I think in the end his current high demands will come down to fit. Call it a hometown discount or just call it smart – staying part of one of the best WR duos in the NFL for a team seemingly built to be in the postseason hunt for the near future should be a no-brainer if & when he gets his offer from the Giants. Reality is, though, he needs them more than they need him. If he’s tendered & walks, he’ll certainly be missed – but a #1 pick & Eli’s ability to churn out successful receivers will ensure it’s not the crippling blow many people think it would be.


are you serious bro? what nicks play like 4 games a year?
“Yes, great decision. Please let Cruz go and keep Nicks.” – Every other NFC East team.
610, stop by the sewing circle some day. Farts says he can kick your ass and Stall thinks you’re his “broh” and Steak is still a dumb hick..
Woody~
If you weren’t a Giants fan I would praise you for having a well thought out article with interesting take. I would even point out that unlike most athletes that are an injury risk in the NFL Nicks never had injury problems in college…. since you are a giants fan I am going to call you a cock-sucking faggot and say you dont know shit about football other than what it feels like to shove one up your ass
You’re spot on here. I’ll take a healthy Nicks, Hixon, Randle, and a 1st round pick if the contract is too much for Victor. It’s sad, but true.
As a Giants fan, if both of these receivers are not locked up long-term, there is a serious fucking front office problem. Osi money comes off, Tuck may or may not be back (1 year left on deal anyway) Bradshaw is 50/50 to play again. Kenny Phillips is a FA, what the FUCK is the problem here? Having 2 dynamic (healthy) receivers is such an advantage in the passing league now. After Julio Jones and Roddy White, there is no better 1-2 combo (when nicks is healthy)
not quite a no brainer both WR’s feed off each other and have some skills that the other doesnt, but you gotta play it smart and go for nicks so theres a first round fallback. after this year giants should have enough money to make a reasonable offer, and no pappelsmear…
Definitely the right move. Look how much the offense struggled without the vertical threat that Nicks gives. He’s the more complete receiver. And Cruz has the 1st round pick insurance.
Nicks over Cruz is a no brainer. You’re #1 receiver in a downfield system can’t run out of the slot.
610 i know the season just ended but if you’re still the giants blogger next season you need to step your shit up. i think you wrote like 5 blogs about them all year and all you do is suck the black unicorns cock. idk how you got this job you fucking suck
Nicks is the best WR on the Giants. He’ll be back after his injury filled season. Fuck the Ravens and old ass Ray Lewis.
Maybe ull make the playoffs next year fags.
They need to cut Webster, he got paid 7 mil to imitate Jason Sehorn all year, that should clear up some space
Remember when you wrote this http://sports.barstoolsports.com/nyc/sports-page/victor-cruzs-impending-free-agency-would-be-a-circus-with-just-about-any-other-organization/ Fucking asshole
got half a paragraph in then realized, who fucking cares?
Pats should immediately trade for gore. He’ll fit right in.
The offense goes as Nicks goes. Unfortunately that has only meant 13/16 games a year lately but Cruz doesnt bring what Nicks does. Bring back Nicks and if Cruz walks Randle is waiting in the wings to take his spot.
And the person hating on Sehorn…fuck you. Sehorn pre-injury was as good as it gets. I’ll never forgive Jim Fucking Fassel for making him return kicks in the fucking preseason.
Cut Webster Diehl and Bradshaw and focus to pay Cruz and Nicks, ( love Bradshaw but). And Ezy E should take a paycut at 20 mill,
first thing you’ve ever posted i can actually agree with
I agree with your blog for the most part nicks is marginally better right now if he returns healthy and this knee injury doesn’t hinder his future speed but your kinda making it out to be a no brainer that nicks should get the long term deal. Cruz was basically the number one all year long without the help nicks had in 2010. When Nicks actually played this yr he had little big play ability since his speed was gone due to playing while injured making him very easy to cover one on one. Though 2010 was nicks’ best yr without cruz, he still had manningham, the nasty trio of earth wind and fire (jacobs, bradshaw, and dj ware which was truly the identity of our team run first) with jake ballard and kevin boss (very productive due to eli’s greatness) The giants are smart and won’t over pay for either, and cruz and nicks know their careers are based on who throws the ball their way so I think they will both be giants for that reason its just a matter of time and money. Cruz and nicks are not manningham and steve smith they are next level players, I just hope the giants don’t think their too smart and low ball one of them and lose em