Top 5 Fictional Baseball Players

KFC,
Not sure if you’ve done this before. You probably have. If you haven’t your’e really shitting the bed. 5 greatest fictional baseball players (from movies obviously, unless theres some fictional baseball books..in which i guess you can include them if you want poindexter)
Matt
You guys think I’m just gonna pick a handful of people from Major League and Angels in the Outfield and Little Big League and shit? For sure not. Gotta think outside the box on this one. Lets fuckin do this dance:
5. Benny The Jet Rodriguez – Benny the Jet was a slick talkin Puerto Rican who dominated the diamond. Dude hit a ball so hard it fucking exploded. Also, in quite possibly the most unrealistic scene in movie history, he’s able to hit a ball directly into Smalls’ glove after telling him “Just stand out there and stick your glove out in the air. I’ll take care of it.” The guy just controlled the diamond. He risked his life against Hercules – thats Love of the Game. I own a pair of PF Flyers because of him. But alas, he checks in at number 5 because he never amounted to anything other than a pinch runner, and I’m not 100% positive he was safe when he stole home
4. The Kid Who Only Hit Homers

Hey Matt you wanna call me a poindexter? Go for it, pal. I’ll be the dude with the fictional baseball team comprised of guys who were fucking blessed by the ghost of George Baruth. No big deal. All he does it hit home runs every single time he steps up to the plate. Pretty sure thats a valuable trait as a baseball player. Was George Baruth real? Was he a ghost? Was he a figment of this kid’s imagination? Who fucking cares the kid hits BOMBS.
3. Marla Hooch

What a hitter! Yea I know shes a chick but her father raised her like a dude once her mom died. She’s ugly as fuck. Basically is a boy. Plus shes a switch hitter. Versatility.
2. Sidd Finch

The greatest April Fools joke of all time. The dude threw 168 mph! One hundred and sixty eight! He wore one shoe while pitching. He mastered control of his body through Tibetan yoga. And he can play the fuckin French horn. He would have been the GOAT.
1. Jake Taylor

When you think of everything a true, blue baseball player is, you think of Jake Taylor. A blue collar, hard working catcher. A team captain with bad knees and nothing else in his life to live for. Not the most talented guy to ever lace them up, but a gritty game. A winner.
Number 2 starter: Henry Rowengartner

When he’s “healthy,” AKA his tendons are wound too tight, he’s unhittable. Now I know what you’re thinking, what about when he loses his arm? What then? Well between the hidden ball trick and “just float it,” Rosenbaker proved he can get outs when he needs them. May not always be pretty but he gets through it.
Closer: Rick Wild Thing Vaughn

And I ain’t talkin about Wild Thing II Rick Vaughn. I don’t want the sell out pussy. I don’t even want the Rick Vaughn from the end of Major League II with the skull and cross bones eyeglasses. I want Major League 1, incarcerated Wild Thing Rick Vaughn who will fuck your wife and strike you out.

When I saw a chick I thought neil wrote this…not good
and kenny powers has to be in the rotation
Are you fucking serious with this shit? Roy Hobbs??? The Natural???? You’re a fucking novice and a joke. I dont even like baseball and even I know Roy Hobbs owns this fucking list. “The best there ever was” It’s the fucking line of the movie. I’m spitting mad with this insult to baseball, American cinematography, and Robert Redford. You fucking mule.
Where’s Billy Chapel in all this? All-time great, perfecto’d the Yanks, still has a cannon apparently. You dropped the ball KFC.
How could you not include Brendan Fraser as Steve Nebraska in The Scout?
And I’m even going to mention that Crash Davis is on this list way before Jake Taylor. You’re an abortion!
I just started liking Neil more than you. How do you feel now? Pretty fucking stupid I’d imagine.
How the fuck is Roy Hobbs not number 1 on this list? No doubt the greatest ball player of all time. Took a gun shot to the gut, hit a homerun while being intentionally walked, and blasted a ball that took out all the lights.
Pablo Sanchez. Racist.
@jimbo slice no, have to agree with Steve Nebraska and great call on the kid who only hit homers, very underrated. Would also include Timothy Busfield in little big league.
Steve Nebraska struck out 27 batters on 81 pitches in Game 7 of the World Series. And he flew into Yankee stadium on a helicopter. He’s the GOAT.
willy mays hays at leadoff is a no-brainer
Jack Parkman. A badass catcher that hits for power.
I want a catcher w/ attitude…Jack fucking Parkman.
Kenny Fuckin’ Powers as my closer.
No Roy Hobbs? Blasphemy without The Natural.
You mention Jake Taylor but not Billy Chapel… If you want a washed up blue collar guy with nothing to live for but baseball, Jake breaks his knees running to first while Chapel throws A NO NO. Pretty clear who’s a better pick KFC. And you take Henry Rosinbagger over Heddo… why not take the cocky juicehead who RUINS PEOPLE’S LIVES.
For Shame.
Joe “Calico Joe” Castle? Bro hit like .750 until Warren Tracey beaned him for fuck sake.
steve nebraska idiot
california penal league
@brownstool69 – you are so right dude. Roy Hobbs is hands down the best fictional player of all time. This list is awful.
And Dotty Hensen was better than Marla Hooch.
Not making this a starting 9 or entire 25 is a travesty. Crash Davis and Willie Mays Hays need roster spots. Also, I’m not sure how you make a blog like this without mentioning the chick who went down on half the Carolina League.
WTF is the kid who only hit homers? KFC, stick to your small eye and your love of men’s genitalia.
Seriously the worst blog on this site ever. How can you fuck up this bad on such a great topic? You’re better than that KFC.
brownstool69 Absofuckinglutely. With the lightning struck tree that killed his father to make the bat out of. WONDERBOY!!!
the only mortal lock on barstool are when list blogs go up and guys like cake eater jimbo_slice come out with a comment like “OMG YOU DIDNT FUCKING INCLUDE THIS GUY? YOURE A FUCKING JOKE! Cry about it bro
Roy Hobbs is easily the most cliche, overdone choice. Step it up fellas.
This is your Bill Buckner moment. Awful blog. No Roy Hobbs. Wow.
NO clu haywood dude rocked the indians
Roy Hobbs is not cliche. He is standard by which to measure. You horses ass.
I told you to think outside the box and you picked the most obvious choice. You guys are lame
Just because he was cut down in his prime doesn’t mean Juan Primo shouldn’t have made this list.
What about Kelly Leak??? “You talkin’ ’bout Kelly Leak? That dude is a bad mutha.” Basically played all 3 outfield positions in one inning!
Why would you think outside the box on a list of the top players by not including the best fictional player?
And what was your “think outside the box” moment? including a dude powered by poltergeists? I’d shut that kid down with a ghost trap from egon so fast your head would spin, then youd be left with a 12 year old with zero power in the middle of your lineup while hobbs shit on your face.
5. Mighty Casey 4. The Kid who only Hit Homeruns 3. Benny the Jet 2. Heddo from rookie of the year. Dude mashed fastballs couldn’t hit underhand fuck cares. 1. The Natural. My pitchers would be Kenny Powers and Rick Vaughn
HELL YEAH ROWENGARTNER
He leads the league in most offensive categories…including nose hair.
All the way May. 5 tool CF that loved to fuck.
I know other people have said this already and I echo what they said. Where the FUCK is Roy Hobbs on this list???!!!!! List is bogus
WAY better roster: http://screenrant.com/baseball-movie-allstar-team-mikee-50671/
Pablo Sanchez and Roy Hobbs for sure. Also what abou Mel clark from angels in the outfield
Pablo Sanchez how’d we forget him.
I’d take Keisha Phillips over the Hooch
Al Bundy in “A man for no seasons” during the baseball strike when he played for the Chicago Cleavage the team sponsored by the strip joint.
Skip to 4:00 mark
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uQDlE49Lgcs&feature=relmfu
Also the clean up hitter in bases loaded for game boy was insane, and anyone who didn’t read Matt Christopher books growing up is a woman
What about the kid in the M&M commercials that hit a home run everytime he eats a green M&M. The kid is straight cash homie!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Top 5 backyard athletes: Pablo Sanchez Pete wheeler Keisha phillips ached Kahn and dmitri petrovuich
James “cool papa” Bell FTW
Mel clark was only good at hackin’ darts….not only did he die young, but he also probbaly harmed his teammates with 2nd hand smoke…F in the teammate column.
I’ve never complained to any of the Barstool guys on here saying they are dumb, don’t know anything……. But I think everyone assumed that the only # 1 could be Roy Hobbs. Seriously, he is the biggest omission ever. Your creditability took a none recoverable hit on this one.
Anyone who picks Crash Davis over Jake Taylor is a fucking loon. Crash played in the Carolina league while Taylor was one of the best catchers in baseball before he blew out his knees. Also major league murders bull durham as a movie
Kenny Kawaguchi GOAT
The fan Bobby Rayburn his stats were insane Willie mays Hayes
The fan Bobby Rayburn his stats were insane Willie mays Hayes
Pedro sorano all day. The voodoo version not the Jesus freak
But there is no joy in Mudville, Mighty Casey has struck out….
No Lou Collins from Little Big League? KFC you asshole. Not only was Lou a all star player, he was banging the managers mom. If that doesn’t get him on this team I don’t know what does.
Where is Chet Stedman? In his hay day they didn’t call him the rocket for no reason
Steve Nebraska’s gotta be on the mound.
How about Jack Elliot at 1B? Not only can he hit intentional balls out of the park, he’s got naked pictures of your wife.
Kevin – You are damn good at your job. Not today though. This was a fucking embarassment. Seriously discrediting yourself here. Fucking Marla Hooch, Rowengartner, Sid… seriously dude? Those aren’t realistic people. Marla did nothing but fantasize about scissoring Rosie O’Donnel the whole time, Rowengrtner, though had a great arm was a big fat clam, and Sid… who the fuck is that? Why did you even read that book? Jake Taylor was good, even Benny the Jet rockin his moustache was good. But you gotta redo this and take it a little more seriously. Clean your shit up. If Roy Hobbs isn’t on your list, let alone number one then you are a fucking clown.
pretty sure Clu Haywood won the Triple crown back in the 87 season.
GUS BUS
Hamilton “The Babe” Porter
Pablo Sanchez FTW Pete Wheeler is a hell of a leadoff hitter too
i thin KFC’s probably the best writer on this site… but this is probably the worst thing he’s ever written. a total mail-it-in hack job….. besides forgetting nebraska and hobbs, he makes the classic blunder of forgetting rick vaughn is a starter and roengarntner is a reliever.
Well you really Munsoned this one Kevin.
Awful list.
so embarrassing KFC. a great idea for a blog, and you completely fuck it up. top 3 has to be pablo sanchez, steve nebraska, and roy hobbs. jake taylor was a fucking bum, sidd finch was a big time pussy
Jon Dowd from mvp ’05 is a no brainer cleanup hitter. Nuke Laloosh just for the sheer amount of pussy he’s gonna bring to your clubhouse. And I need a post-gunshot G-baby on my team. Nothing like a dead teammate to light a fire under your teams ass
Such a great topic and you butchered it, May God have mercy on your soul…. not including steve nebraska and roy hobbs is a disgrace thatshould be punished by either your resignation or banishment to barstoolboston with those jerkoffs.
You forgot player/manager Cecil “Stud” Cantrell
Carlos Liston? Thou shalt not make fun of Carlos Liston or thou will get their asses whipped.
Starting Line-up: 1) Willie Mays-Hayes CF, Major League. 2) Pablo Sanchez, SS, Backyard Baseball. 3) Roy Hobbs, LF, The Natural. 4) Pedro Cerano, RF, Major League. 5) Lou Collins, 1B, Little Big League. 6) Jack Parkman, DH, Major League 2. 7) Ray Mitchell, 3B, Angels in the Outfield. 8) Mickey Scales, 2B, Little Big League. 9) Jake Taylor, C, Major League.
Bench: 1) Roger Dorn, 3B, Major League. 2) Benny “The Jet” Rodriguez, INF, The Sandlot. 3) Pete Wheeler, INF/OF, Backyard Baseball. 4) Crash Davis, C, Bull Durham. 5) Clu Haywood, 1B, Major League.
Starting Rotation: 1) Billy Chapel, RHP, For Love of the Game. 2) Mel Clark, RHP, Angels in the Outfield. 3) Chet Steadman, RHP, Rookie of the Year. 4) Eddie Harris, Major League. 5) Nuke LaLoosh, RHP, Bull Durham.
Bullpen: 1) Ricky “Wild Thing” Vaughn, RHP/Closer, Major League. 2) Henry Rowengartner, RHP/Set-Up Man, Rookie of the Year. 3) Duke Temple, RHP, Major League. 4) Schoup, LHP, Major League 2. 5) Whitt Bass, RHP, Angels in the Outfield. 6) Jim Bowers, RHP, Little Big League.
Manager: Lou Brown, Major League.
GM: Charlie Donovan, Major League.
Owner: Billy Heywood, Little Big League.
Don’t get laid much, do ya fge2000?
What about Mickey Kaline, from Hey Arnold?
Bugs Bunny is an absolute no brainer.
Heddo when he hits the dong off rowengartner and goes ,SEE YA! “waah Kid..wheres mommy!”.
You want outside the box – how bout Can’t-Get-Right from that Eddie Murphy movie Life. That dumb mute whacks the shit out of the ball. Hell he was so good he went and got himself a pardon and became a free man. Plus he knocked up the warden’s white daughter. Champion.
This list is so terrible, it’s embarrassing. The name of this website shouldn’t have anything to do with sports.